Sample chapter

03

Einstein’s
problem

Can quantum mechanics tell us what happens to an individual particle?

In 1927, as the new quantum theory was being debated at the Solvay Conference in Brussels, Einstein pressed a deceptively simple question. Imagine a beam of particles arriving one by one at a narrow slit, with a bank of detectors arranged beyond it.

After passing through the slit, the quantum wave spreads out. Its intensity reaches every detector, and quantum theory predicts the probability that each one will fire. Yet an individual particle always produces one definite event: a single flash at a single detector.

Wave and particle. The wave spreads towards every detector, but the particle produces only one result.

One event, many possibilities

What, then, determines where that particle arrives? The standard theory supplies probabilities for the possible outcomes, but it does not describe a path from slit to detector. For Einstein, that left the account incomplete. A theory ought to say something about the individual event, not only the statistics of many repeated events.

How does one particular possibility become the event that actually happens?

De Broglie’s answer

Louis de Broglie had already proposed a strikingly direct answer. The particle is real and has a definite position at every moment. It is accompanied by a wave, and the form of that wave guides its motion. The wave passes through the slit and spreads; the particle passes through too, following one path within the wave’s changing flow.

Repeat the experiment with particles starting at slightly different positions and the paths fan out. Together their arrival points reproduce the familiar diffraction pattern. Each event is definite, while the distribution of many events has the wave-like form predicted by quantum mechanics.

A family of possible trajectories. Each particle follows just one.

What the picture changes

Nothing changes in the experimental predictions. What changes is the story we can tell about the physical world. The particle does not vanish into a cloud of possibilities and reappear at a detector. It moves continuously, guided by a wave whose structure determines the possible paths.

This is the first glimpse of the de Broglie–Bohm world: quantum, non-classical, but definite.